A Catholic answer
Why is Peter considered the first pope?
The short answer
Jesus singled Peter out. He renamed him "Rock," promised to build his Church on him and gave him the keys of the kingdom Matthew 16:18–19. He prayed for Peter so that he could strengthen his brothers Luke 22:31–32, and after the Resurrection he told him three times to feed his sheep John 21:15–17. Peter led the early Church and died in Rome, and the bishops of Rome have carried on his office ever since Catechism 881 Catechism 882.
A new name with a mission
When Jesus first met Simon, he gave him a new name: Cephas, Aramaic for "rock," which in Greek is Peter John 1:42. In Scripture, when God changes someone's name, he is giving them a new mission, as when Abram became Abraham Genesis 17:5. Later, after Peter confessed that Jesus is the Christ, Jesus said: "thou art Peter; and upon this rock I will build my church" (Douay-Rheims) Matthew 16:18.
The keys of the kingdom
Jesus then gave Peter the keys of the kingdom of heaven and the power to bind and loose Matthew 16:19. His Jewish listeners would have recognized the image from Isaiah: the king's chief steward held the key of the house of David, and what he opened no one could shut Isaiah 22:22. The keys mean authority to govern the household on the king's behalf. The other apostles also received the power to bind and loose Matthew 18:18, but only Peter received the keys Catechism 553 Catechism 881.
Peter leads the early Church
Peter is named first in every list of the apostles Matthew 10:2. He preaches the first sermon at Pentecost Acts 2:14–41, and at the Council of Jerusalem his words settle the debate over the Gentiles Acts 15:7–11. After his conversion, Paul went up to Jerusalem specifically to see Peter Galatians 1:18.
Peter and Rome
Peter's first letter sends greetings from "Babylon" 1 Peter 5:13, a name early Christians used for Rome. Ancient Christian writers agree that Peter and Paul were martyred in Rome. Around AD 180, Saint Irenaeus listed the bishops of Rome in order, starting from the Church founded there by Peter and Paul (Against Heresies, Book 3, chapter 3). The title "pope" came later; the office is what goes back to Peter.
What the pope is, and isn't
Christ is the head of the Church Catechism 792. The pope is his servant: the bishop of Rome and Peter's successor, "the perpetual and visible source and foundation of the unity" of the bishops and the faithful Catechism 882. Infallibility does not mean the pope never sins or is right about everything. It applies only when he solemnly defines a teaching of faith or morals for the whole Church Catechism 891.
Still have a question?
Ask Restless anything about this. You'll get a clear answer with the Scripture and Catechism sources to check it.
Ask your own questionRelated questions
Sources
Scripture links open the New American Bible at the U.S. bishops' site. Catechism links open the paragraph in the USCCB's online Catechism.
Go deeper
Short books from Restless Faith Media on this question.
Pocket Guide · Book 1
Why Good Protestants Become Catholic
And Why Catholics Who Don't Know Their Faith Often Leave
Who it's for: For anyone wrestling with sola scriptura, the papacy, Mary, or the Eucharist — and wondering why serious Protestants keep following Scripture and history into the Catholic Church.
View on Amazon
Pocket Guide · Book 6
What Jesus Taught Us
Who it's for: What did Jesus actually expect his followers to do after the Ascension? A Church, a pastoral office, the Eucharist, forgiveness, mission — Catholic life as a response to him, not an addition.
View on Amazon